Thursday, October 22, 2026

myanimelist highest rated anime of ALL TIME

for some reason, i recently became conscious of the fact that ive always known Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood as "the highest rated anime on myanimelist." i think i might have heard that mentioned one time in a video i watched or something, and i just internalized the information as an undisputed fact? (i wasnt ever actually checking the stats.) i dont remember if i thought of that as a prestigious designation at the time but at this point the factoid registers as 100% useless information and enters my headspace like dust mote might float carelessly through a shaft of light for a moment before vanishing out of sight. 
also, this isnt even true anymore i just realized (what the fuck is "Frieren?") 
so i did some research and the history of the top anime on myanimelist since 2007 goes like this

2007: Death Note
2008: Rouroni Kenshin: Tsuiokuhen
2009: Gurren Lagann
2010: Gurren Lagann
2011: Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood
2012: Gintama
2013: Gintama
2014: Gintama
2015: Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood
2016: Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood
2017: Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood
2018: Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood
2019: Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood
2020: Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood
2021: Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood
2022: Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood
2023: Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood
2024: Sosou no Frieren
2025: Sosou no Frieren
2026: Sosou no Frieren

(i got this from the wayback machine) 

some notes on this data: Fullmetal had the best run, but the top 10 is very trend-sensitive, so it would occasionally be overshadowed for a month or two by a newer, popular thing (this happened with Kimi No Na Wa in 2017 for instance) but overall it stayed strong.  
Stein's Gate has always had a strong rating and usually appears in second place. 
in recent years, FMAB hit second and even third place, and the second place rating is changing constantly based on current trends. 
Evangelion 2.0 You Can (Not) Advance was rated extremely high (6th place) in 2011 and slowly fell several ranks in the span of 2012-13 and then in 2014-16 fell completely off the top 10, the same timespan when 3.0 was released in America. i guess it reframed peoples opinions of the second movie a lot. the opinions of myanimelist users are also often wrong. in fact, ive gathered that myanimelist users are so overwhelmingly wrong about almost everything to the point that you can basically take what they say and assume the exact opposite most of the time. 

anyway, ratings obviously kind of communicate more about the people submitting them then they do about the thing theyre rating itself. for the most part, anime is, like almost no other medium, hyper-tergeted to specific types of people in incredibly niche in-groups, so there will always be people who just arent receiving the message. this is what tends to cause anime fandom to be full of people who say "i like anime, but not THAT kind of anime." 

knowing that, the top 10 seems to represent the anime which speak to the most general audience within the landscape of english-speaking, usually American weebs. so who is being represented by this data? the median average american weeaboo in 2016? im guessing that would probably be a guy, maybe around 17, white, and i cant imagine he wouldnt be an athiest. 

wait, doesnt this guy sound...  kinda familiar? 



sorry im sure this isnt coming as a shock but i did find it kinda funny listening to eds dialogue on this rewatch. its really sending me back. i dont even have anything bad i wanna say about the show either its great. deserves classic status. the end. 





No comments:

Post a Comment